Always Cold and Tired This Winter? When to Check Your Thyroid

By Dr. Threasa Andrys, ND, Founder

November in Fargo means shorter days, colder mornings, and a lot of people saying they feel "run down." Some of that is the season. But in clinic, this is also the time of year when I see patients whose fatigue, cold intolerance, and brain fog turn out to have a clearer cause: an underactive thyroid.

The thyroid is a small gland at the front of your neck, but its hormones help set the pace for nearly every cell in your body, including heat production, heart rate, digestion, menstrual cycles, skin and hair turnover, and mood. When thyroid output drops, everything tends to slow down. Because those symptoms overlap so much with "winter in North Dakota," thyroid problems are easy to miss.

Common signs of an underactive thyroid

Hypothyroidism often develops gradually, over months or years. Common symptoms include:

  • Feeling cold when others are comfortable, especially cold hands and feet

  • Fatigue that doesn't improve much with sleep

  • Brain fog, slower thinking, or trouble concentrating

  • Unexplained weight gain or difficulty losing weight

  • Constipation

  • Dry skin, brittle nails, or thinning hair (including the outer edge of the eyebrows)

  • Low mood or low motivation

  • Heavier or more irregular periods

  • Puffiness in the face or around the eyes

  • Muscle aches or stiffness

None of these is specific to the thyroid on its own. Low iron, low vitamin D, poor sleep, depression, perimenopause, and seasonal affective patterns can all look similar, which is exactly why testing matters more than guessing.

Who is at higher risk?

Thyroid disease is common, and some groups are affected more often:

  • Women, who are several times more likely than men to develop thyroid disease

  • People in the postpartum period or in perimenopause

  • Anyone with a personal or family history of thyroid disease

  • People with another autoimmune condition, such as celiac disease, type 1 diabetes, or rheumatoid arthritis

  • People trying to conceive, since thyroid function affects ovulation and early pregnancy

In the United States, the most common cause of hypothyroidism is Hashimoto's thyroiditis, an autoimmune condition in which the immune system gradually damages the thyroid. This is one reason we look at thyroid health through the wider lens of autoimmunity, digestive health, and inflammation, not just one hormone number.

Why "your TSH is normal" isn't always the whole story

TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone) is the standard screening test, and it is a good one. It comes from the pituitary gland and rises when the thyroid isn't keeping up. But TSH alone can miss part of the picture. A more complete thyroid panel often includes:

  • TSH: the pituitary's signal to the thyroid

  • Free T4: the main hormone the thyroid produces

  • Free T3: the more active form, mostly converted from T4 in tissues like the liver and gut

  • TPO antibodies and thyroglobulin antibodies: markers of autoimmune thyroid disease, which can be elevated years before TSH changes

Because thyroid symptoms overlap with other common deficiencies, I often look at a few related markers at the same time, such as ferritin (iron stores), vitamin D, vitamin B12, and a basic metabolic and blood count panel.

A few practical testing tips:

  • Stop biotin before testing. Biotin (in many hair, skin, and nail supplements and B-complexes) can interfere with thyroid lab results. Ask your provider how long to hold it; a few days is common.

  • Test consistently. If you're tracking results over time, try to test at a similar time of day and under similar conditions.

  • Don't change thyroid medication on your own based on a single lab value or symptom.

You can order many of these labs yourself through our Fullscript store, then bring the results to a visit so we can interpret them together in context.

What about "subclinical" hypothyroidism?

Sometimes TSH is mildly elevated while free T4 is still in range. This is called subclinical hypothyroidism. It doesn't always need medication, but it deserves attention, especially if you have positive antibodies, symptoms, or are trying to conceive or are pregnant, where targets are typically tighter. Rechecking labs and addressing contributing factors is often a reasonable first step.

Supporting thyroid health: what the evidence supports

There is no single "thyroid diet" that works for everyone. Several dietary approaches can support thyroid health, and the right one depends on your symptoms, lab results, digestion, and personal history. Part of our work together is identifying the eating pattern that best supports your thyroid and fits your life. Beyond diet, several factors make a meaningful difference:

Key nutrients. The thyroid relies on iodine, selenium, zinc, and iron. Iodine deserves particular attention. As more people replace iodized table salt with sea salt, Himalayan salt, and other unrefined salts, I have seen a noticeable rise in iodine-related thyroid concerns in my practice over the past five years. Testing your iodine status and regularly including iodine-rich foods, such as seafood and seaweed, can help prevent these problems. Because both too little and too much iodine can disrupt thyroid function, particularly in Hashimoto's, high-dose iodine or kelp supplements should only be used with guidance and based on testing. Selenium (found in Brazil nuts, fish, and eggs) has some evidence for lowering thyroid antibodies in Hashimoto's, but it also has an upper safety limit, so dosing should be deliberate.

Iron and ferritin. Low iron stores are common, especially in women with heavy periods, and can both mimic and worsen thyroid symptoms.

Gut health. Absorption of thyroid medication and key nutrients depends on a healthy digestive tract. Celiac disease is more common in people with autoimmune thyroid disease, and conditions like low stomach acid or chronic gut inflammation can affect absorption.

Blood sugar, sleep, and stress. Chronic stress and poor sleep affect the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid axis and T4-to-T3 conversion. Regular meals with enough protein, consistent sleep, and daily movement are unglamorous but foundational.

Body composition. Thyroid changes can shift metabolism and muscle mass. An InBody 580 body composition scan ($65, with Bree Pierce, RN) gives a baseline of muscle, fat, and water balance so you can track meaningful change over time, rather than relying on the scale alone.

When medication makes sense

For many people with confirmed hypothyroidism, thyroid hormone replacement is the right choice, and it can make a profound difference in how they feel. At Fargo Naturopathic, Dr. Threasa Andrys can prescribe thyroid medication when it's indicated. In addition to levothyroxine, she prescribes natural desiccated thyroid medications such as Armour Thyroid and NP Thyroid, which contain both T4 and T3. Many patients seek out a provider who is open to trying desiccated thyroid when they haven't felt their best on T4-only medication. The right medication and dose are chosen individually, based on your symptoms, your full thyroid panel, and how you respond over time.

Still symptomatic on thyroid medication?

Medication is not the complete answer for everyone. Some patients continue to struggle with fatigue, weight gain, hair loss, brain fog, or feeling cold even when their prescription and TSH appear to be on target. Many of our patients come to us for exactly this reason: they are looking for someone to explain why their thyroid still isn't functioning well.

When symptoms persist, we look for the underlying reasons, which may include:

  • Poor T4-to-T3 conversion, so the body isn't making enough of the active hormone

  • Nutrient deficiencies such as iron, selenium, zinc, or iodine

  • Absorption problems related to gut health, low stomach acid, celiac disease, or the timing of medication with food, coffee, or supplements

  • Ongoing autoimmune activity in Hashimoto's

  • Inflammation, chronic stress, or blood sugar imbalance

  • Other hormone imbalances, including sex hormones and cortisol

  • A medication type or dose that isn't the right fit

Our goal is to find what is standing in the way, improve thyroid function, and help you feel like yourself again. All of our providers work alongside your treatment to address these contributing factors.

If you already take thyroid medication, a few tips help it work well:

  • Take it consistently, usually on an empty stomach with water.

  • Separate it from calcium, iron, and magnesium supplements and from coffee, typically by several hours for minerals. Your pharmacist or provider can give you exact timing.

  • Recheck labs after any dose change, pregnancy, or significant weight change.

The bottom line

Feeling a little slower in a Fargo November is normal. Feeling cold, exhausted, foggy, and stuck month after month is not something you just have to push through. A thorough thyroid workup, read alongside your symptoms, nutrient status, and history, can give you real answers and a clear plan.

This article is for general education and is not medical advice. Please talk with your healthcare provider before starting supplements or changing any medication.

Ready to get answers? Book online at fargonaturopathic.janeapp.com or call us at (701) 314-4008 to schedule with Dr. Threasa Andrys, Dr. Andrea Hillstad, or Dr. Kristen Couture, ND.

And for more seasonal health tips, sign up for our newsletter at the bottom of this page.

Dr. Threasa Andrys

Hi Everyone, 

I am Dr. Threasa Andrys, naturopathic doctor, wife, mother, animal enthusiast, seeker of nature and home cook.  

http://drthreasaandrys.com
Next
Next

Beating the North Dakota Winter Blues